Team 1
positive:
- Your game idea is somewhat unique, which is interesting.
negative:
- We think it might be difficult to make the game balaced. (Especially because this depends solely on you, while the user just enjoys the game, instead of working on the balance of the game.) Try to include the user more in the process by providing them some mechanism to adjust some values (at what place will be how many particles etc.)
Team 2
Team 3
Team 5
Positive:
- I like meddling on a metalevel and it is interesting to change the base for the unit creation
- Simple choice model with good potential to become more difficult over time (i.e. interesting for expert players)
Negative:
- Fixed genetic possibility. I would prefer to be able to explore genetic combinations and "remember" those I've found. That would force me to decide between propping up my units on the field and having more temporary control or risking looking for new units to fight in the later game.
Team 6
A (too detailed) feedback can be found
here
